The Ten Creepiest Masked Killers of All-Time

The Ten Creepiest Masked Killer of All-Time

Editor’s Note: The feature article below was contributed to by multiple members of the FSR Staff, but compiled by our own resident horror buff Robert Fure.

With Halloween coming up, 31 Days of Horror in full swing, and the release of the creepy flick The Strangers on DVD, we thought it was about time to look back on the history of the masked killer and pull out the creepiest of the creepy. The masked killer has become a staple image in our minds when we think of horror movies or serial killers, though despite that, there are actually relatively few menacing ones. Here are our top ten.

10. Mrs. Tredoni (Alice, Sweet Alice)

Alice, Sweet Alice

What’s creepy about this is how decidedly uncreepy it is in pieces. A giant cliched yellow rain slicker? A girly Valentine’s like mask? Who would have thought that pairing them together would create a slick, creepy killer?

9. Torso’s Masked Killer (Torso)

Torso Killer

This guy is creepy because you have this outfit in your closet already. A knit cap with hand cut holes, leather gloves, this is the kind of person who shows up randomly in your backyard and scares the poop out of you.

8. Scream Killers (Scream)

Scream Mask

The mask that launched a million Halloween costumes. What we like about the Scream mask that it has emotion frozen into it, rather than a lack of emotion like most blank slate masks. Definitely a cool look for a while that has totally been overplayed.

7. The Strangers (The Strangers)

The Strangers

The atmosphere of this movie helps out these masked killers who could be anyone you know and thats what makes them scary. Regular clothing, creepy children’s masks, a baghead, these aren’t who you want to see in the dark.

6. Satan (Satan’s Little Helper)

Satan's Little Helper

What I really like about this mask is that it is literally off the shelf of a Halloween costume store, and just as importantly, within the film it still works. This serial killer utilizes his costume store mask to blend in on Halloween and even feel up some boobs.

5. Michael Myers (Halloween)

Michael Myers

All we need say is “Because a silent, pasty William Shatner is a scary William Shatner.” One of the all time classic masked killers, Myers’ pasty face peering down at your, with Shatner’s mane of hair sticking up, is terrifying.

4. Jigsaw Pig Mask (Saw)

Jigsaw Pig Mask

While not occupying nearly enough screen time, the pig mask of the Saw series is a righteous mask that is actually the cut off head of a pig, not some latex or foam creation. Well, in the movie it’s real, at least, and that is awesome, bloody, and scary.

3. Jason Voorhees (Friday the 13th Series)

Jason Voorhees

Perhaps the most recognized killer of all time, he also rocks one of the most memorable masks in film history. Whether you prefer his baghead look from Friday the 13th II or his classic hockey mask, there is no denying Jason is one bad mother set to tear the screen up again and again.

2. Leatherface (Texas Chainsaw Massacre Series)


When your mask is created from the severed flesh and faces of your victims, you’re an ultimate badass. This grotesque visage will haunt the nightmares of many a viewer long after the credits roll.

1. The Scarecrow (Dark Night of the Scarecrow)

Dark Night of the Scarecrow

You may not have heard of this made for TV horror special, but let me tell you, this Scarecrow is creepy as all hell. Huge, dark eye holes, a gaping maw of a mouth, armed with a pitchfork, this visage will stop you from cutting through the cornfields late at night.

There you have it – our ten creepiest masked killers in cinematic history. While we can and will argue their placements and wonder why some didn’t make the cut, I think we can all agree that this is a list of people you definitely do not want to catch a glimpse of down a dark alley.

Want to tell us who you’d pick as the Creepiest Masked Killer of All-Time? Head over to our discussion thread here.