Year In Review: 11 Movies You People Wouldn’t Shut Up About In 2011

This started out as a list of overrated movies, but we (“we” being Rob Hunter and Kevin Carr, rabblerousers) decided fairly quickly that “overrated” is an overused and abused term. Who are we, or anyone, to tell you that you like a movie too much? It’s a rude thing to say regardless of whether or not we’re right. But thanks to the internet sometimes one person’s exuberance can find a virtual megaphone in all the tubes and anonymous users online, and that misguided praise can become deafening. And yes, we’re just as guilty as the rest of you…especially in regard to our first pick below.

To be clear, most of these are not bad movies. The majority of them are actually good. But none of them deserved the near-constant accolades that seemed to echo from one corner of the web to another ad nauseum. So without further ado, pomp, or circumstance, here are 11 12 movies (in alphabetical order) you people wouldn’t shut up about in 2011. (**Note, there may be a few minor spoilers below.**)

Attack the Block

At the risk of losing an audience right out of the gate…yes, I’m saying Joe Cornish‘s little alien invasion flick was undeserving of the ridiculous amount of internet praise heaped upon it. Bear with me here. There’s no doubt this is a fun and breezily entertaining film, but it was hardly the masterful mash-up of Steven Spielberg and Joe Dante bloggers proclaimed. The idea that it weaves any relevant thread of social/class warfare between its action scenes and occasionally-unintelligible dialogue is just ludicrous, and finding out Moses doesn’t have parents ten minutes before the credits roll hardly makes up for the fact that he and his friends are mugging people at knife-point. The alien design is cool and the movie’s more fun than Super 8 (also on this list), but attitude and some incredibly sharp camera work are no replacement for true heart and character depth. -RH


Writer/director/actor Evan Glodell won over a lot of people with his mufti-hyphenate appeal, on-set camera rig inventions, love of Mad Max and offers of free rides in his admittedly cool car, Medusa, but none of that makes for a great movie. Instead his rumination on male friendship, the deceitful nature of women and an eventual descent into madness all ring occasionally false and ridiculous. The film has an interesting style, but the script gets in the way of telling a coherent story. The even bigger problem here is Glodell’s acting ability. His non-existent acting ability. He pretty much whines his way through the entire film. It’s highly annoying and overshadows the more appealing elements of the film, and hopefully he’ll forgo stepping in front of the camera the next time he steps behind it. -RH


If you listen to the right people, you’d think that Bridesmaids was the most unique, original, female-empowering film ever made. And sure, it has its merits, but funniest film of the 2011 summer? Hardly. This movie may be heralded as being another hilarious Judd Apatow-produced comedy, but it suffers from the standard Apatow problems: a bloated running time and often unlikeable characters. (P.S. I grew up with a mom and a sister, and I’m married now. I’m fully aware that women poop.) -KC

The Descendants

Like many films that come out during award season, this latest George Clooney grab at Oscar was buzzed about before it even made it to theaters. And sure, it has some fine elements to it. But when all the emotional angst is pulled away, there’s very little character growth from a crummy parent who doesn’t become any better of a parent by the end of the movie. -KC


Midnight in Paris

Come on, people. I get that Owen Wilson‘s interactions with long dead literary characters are fun and playful, but every second of this movie that isn’t spent traipsing through the streets of post-midnight Paris is aggravating as hell. The normally lovely Rachel McAdams annoys with every word and motion, and Wilson’s character takes ninety minutes of heavy handed abuse before finally catching a clue. The only thing magical here is how this bland and basic tale attracted a bigger audience than the superior (and admittedly less comedic) Match Point. -RH

Super 8

JJ Abrams‘s love letter to Steven Spielberg’s Amblin Entertainment appears on the surface to hit all the right notes, but even a cursory glance reveals a hollow and false foundation. After a pretty solid first hour the film devolves into inane set pieces, contrivances, and an unearned and unsatisfying conclusion. Joe’s issues with his distant dad? Magically resolved. The implied emotional weight given to his mother’s locket? Meh. The bonding moment between lost boy and murderous alien? Confusing. Hopefully next time Abrams will worry more about a coherent and heart-warming script than about how to justify lens flare in a dark cave. -RH

Take Shelter

Yes, Michael Shannon is the man. He’s been knocking around for the better part of two decades, and was honored only a few years ago with an Academy Award nomination for Revolutionary Road. Shannon was also good in Take Shelter, but the film itself is lesser than his performance. It falls into plenty of low-budget award film cliches, from portraying average Americans as dull, drab, and humorless to spotlighting too many obvious Oscar clips and having a painfully predictable ending. -KC

Transformers: The Dark of the Moon

While this film was appropriately raked over the critical coals this summer, audiences flocked to see Michael Bay’s latest testosterone ejaculation…in 3D! Transformers: Dark of the Moon made so much money that it became the fourth highest grossing film in the world, eclipsing far better $1B movies like The Dark Knight, Toy Story 3 and Lord of the Rings: Return of the King. And the blame is universal, considering more than $770 million of its gross was garnered overseas. Congratulations, planet Earth. You just guaranteed more of these mind-numbing and incomprehensible explosion extravaganzas for the next dozen years. -KC

Tree of Life

It’s a polarizing movie, sure, so consider me on the pole opposite many critics out there. Beautiful cinematography couldn’t save this pretentious, indulgent, overlong, unsubtle mess of a movie. Any argument for artistic merit and deeper meaning in its cinematic mosaic is lost in scenes with Jessica Chastain pointing to the sky and declaring, “That’s where God lives” and nonsensical tantric yoga at the film’s climax. -KC


How do any one of these trolls sneak up on a single person? Or a bear? Even by “found footage film” standards, this is a weak entry aside from the troll effects as the story gets dragged out too long for too little. -RH

Tie – Warrior / We Need To Talk About Kevin

I respectfully disagree with the honorable Mr. Hunter on Warrior. It’s not a triumph or gripping film…not when you see the trailers and know not only that the main characters are brothers (a fact that’s supposed to be a surprise in the film), but also that they’re going to fight each other in the championship. Add to this the uninspired overuse of Beethoven’s “Ode to Joy” as a training song and the achingly unsubtle obsession Nick Nolte’s character has with Moby Dick, it’s clear this film just tries too hard to rise above itself. -KC

We Need To Talk About Kevin does not work as a drama because the boy is a cartoon villain. It does not work as horror because the most frightening element is Tilda Swinton‘s wardrobe. It does not work as a musical because there are no musical numbers. It does not work as a comedy because it feels like a Friedberg/Seltzer riff on “devil-kid” movies. Okay, that last one may have been a bit harsh. -RH

The FSR Staff is an author similar to Hydra. Its articles have many authors. It has many heads. Please don't cut off any of its heads, we're trying to work here.

Read More from FSR Staff
Get Film School Rejects in your email. All the cool kids are doing it:
Previous Article
Next Article
Reject Nation
Leave a comment
Comment Policy: No hate speech allowed. If you must argue, please debate intelligently. Comments containing selected keywords or outbound links will be put into moderation to help prevent spam. Film School Rejects reserves the right to delete comments and ban anyone who doesn't follow the rules. We also reserve the right to modify any curse words in your comments and make you look like an idiot. Thank You!