SXSW Interview: Vincenzo Natali Suffers for Originality

natali 2

It’s interesting, though, because maybe a lot of Cube fans would disagree it’d be better with a bigger budget.

Maybe, yeah. These are all hypothetical questions. I’m a great believer that movies are time capsules. You do them at a certain time with the resources you have in the way that you can. You just should never look back. I will never do a George Lucas. In a way, the movies that I love are all flawed. And I love them as much for their flaws as anything else. If you start to tinker with them they are imagined versions of them where they would…It’s like if you fall in love with a person you love the whole package. So yeah, so I embrace my films [Laughs], even with their flaws!

And the good news is, with every one of them, because they’ve been in the sort of lower budgeted realm, and because I’ve worked with good people, I’ve always had final cut. That’s the one thing I would be loathed to give up.

I read that you’ve had final cut on all your movies. How did you luck out so early?

[Laughs] Again, sometimes it’s by design, sometimes it’s side of indifference. Like when I made Cypher, which is a movie not many people have seen, the Weinstein’s at that time, Miramax, had it, and they are notorious for re-cutting movies and tearing them apart. With my movie, I just don’t think they even noticed I made it. [Laughs] They didn’t even know! Or care. So the upside of that was they didn’t tinker with it. The downside was that they didn’t release it and stuck it in a vault [Laughs]. But so not by design, but by sort or accident in that case I had final cut. I made exactly the movie I wanted to make.

Do you prefer that, getting it put in the vault with you being completely responsible for it, or the idea of it released on 2,000 screens where maybe the Weinstein’s did do their tinkering?

I think that would be very easy to say yes. In truth, no. I think everyone wants their movie to be seen. But definitely there’s a limit. There’s a point where it would stop being my movie and then I wouldn’t want people to see that. So a little tinkering is perhaps all right. But it’s a consolation price for not having my film released. [Laughs] I look at it that way.

Your movies can have woefully strange quality to them where they won’t ever be for everyone. Have you known for a while that’s just the type of filmmaker you are?

Exactly. They’re not intended to be [for everyone]. Actually, Haunter is probably, I would guess, the most accessible thing I’ve done. Again, not by intention. That’s just sort of how it is. But even it’s pretty weird. And, yeah, life is weird. [Laughs] At least it is to me.

You know, the funny thing is when you live with these things for a long time, or as long as I did with Splice, which actually was well over a decade, you kind of forget how weird it is. [Laughs] Just because you become accustomed to it. And then when I actually showed the film to people, they just went berserk. I remember those screenings. And, invariably, in the lovemaking scene, people just went bananas. They weren’t quiet about it either. They were screaming at the screen! So, yeah, it’s funny.

Do you like it when you see that response?

Yes, well that movie is meant to be provocative for sure. I mean it would have been a failure, in my opinion, if it hadn’t incited extreme reactions. I certainly didn’t expect it to go kind of middle of the road.

With Haunter, are there any moments where it pushes an audience’s buttons?

No. I see Haunter…I don’t want to disappoint people. People who are expecting Splice and just something that’s totally subversive are not going to get that with Haunter at all. Haunter is a much more traditional kind of ghost story. Although, at the same time, what Brian has done has created something that I don’t believe I’ve ever seen in a movie before. But it’s not a subversive film. It’s a very, I believe, quite cleverly constructed sort of labyrinth-like ghost story. But it doesn’t have the intention of shocking people.

Without spoiling the movie, what was it that Brian did that is so different?

It’s sort of a ghost story inside out. It’s this dead teenager and she is reliving the same day in 1985 over, and over, and over with her family, only she is the only member of her family who is aware that they are all dead. And it is about her attempt to solve the mystery as to why this is happening.

So it’s really…it’s kind of picking up, I suppose, where The Sixth Sense or the others left off, because our ghost knows that she’s a ghost from the opening of the movie. It’s a very moody, atmospheric, as I say, labyrinth…it’s my gentle side. [Laughs]

[Laughs] Which I imagine still won’t be that gentle.

No, it’s not too gentle.

So should we never expect a romantic comedy from you? 

[Laughs] No, I don’t think you are going to…Well, who knows? Never say never. I’ve been toying with a musical. How about that?

An original one?

A totally original thing, yeah. There’s a musician I am very close with and we’ve been talking about it for years. So you never know. Never say never.

It sounds like you are taking up another challenge, making an original movie and a musical.

Yeah, exactly. It’s so hard. I just got an email back from a very prominent company—I won’t name them—whom I like tremendously, who I had sent both 15 pages of an original script I’m writing and the script that Brian has written. And the response was: “We love this, but we don’t think we can get it made.” [Laughs]

Unfortunately, we’re just living in a time where movies are extremely expensive and people aren’t willing to take chances very often. So that’s kind of the cross that one has to bear. But it is…I try hard not to get bitter or frustrated about it because that’s just the way it is, and probably always has been, actually. It’s just that movies now are so much more expensive than they have ever been and it’s so much more expensive to release them that it makes it harder for everybody.

Do you ever see yourself going the Edward Burns route, making the movie yourself and just putting it out there for people online?

I think in a way I always have been. All the movies I’ve made, honestly, they are made like home movies that have a crew. I have a professional crew and so on. But at the end of the day it’s just me, the camera, and I’m playing with Barbie dolls. Like literally shooting stuff in my basement to make all the features fit together because we just never have enough money.

On one hand I get frustrated by that because I just want to be able to do more. On the other hand, I sort of like it because there’s a handmade quality to it, and I like doing handmade things. So yeah, no, I sort of feel like I’m already there, really. But as I say, with something like Neuromancer, I can’t do that in my basement. All of these films, even Splice, which is the most expensive one I’ve made, they are designed only to have a few characters in a few locations. Because when you don’t have as much money, what you want to do is limit the number of elements that you are working with so you can maximize your resources.

But a movie like Neuromancer, it, by definition, covers multiple continents. It goes into outer space, cyberspace, everywhere. And that’s just a different kind of filmmaking. But I’d like to go there. I really would love to be able to stay in that ballpark. So it’s all good.

All you really need to know about Jack is his favorite movies are: The Last Detail, Rumble Fish, Sunset Boulevard, The Truman Show, Raiders of the Lost Ark, Dead Men Don't Wear Plaid, The Verdict, Closer, Shadow of a Doubt, Spider-Man 2, Jaws, Adaptation, Get Carter, The Last Days of Disco, Carnal Knowledge, Almost Famous, Ed Wood, Barton Fink, and L.A. Confidential.

Read More from Jack Giroux
Get Film School Rejects in your email. All the cool kids are doing it:
Previous Article
Next Article
Reject Nation
Leave a comment
Comment Policy: No hate speech allowed. If you must argue, please debate intelligently. Comments containing selected keywords or outbound links will be put into moderation to help prevent spam. Film School Rejects reserves the right to delete comments and ban anyone who doesn't follow the rules. We also reserve the right to modify any curse words in your comments and make you look like an idiot. Thank You!